The Requirement of Judicial Reasons in Civil, Commercial and Family Litigation
Justice requires an articulated path of reasoning.
When a court disposes of commercial real estate, corporate shares, or substantial family property, the parties are entitled to understand how the tribunal arrived at its conclusion.
When a trial judge or chambers judge grants orders without explaining how conflicting evidence was resolved or which legal principles were applied, the judicial function fails.
Under British Columbia law, giving reasons for judgment is an essential aspect of the judicial role. As established by the Supreme Court of Canada in R. v. Sheppard, and F.H. v. McDougall, judicial reasons serve 3 primary functions:
- Explaining to the unsuccessful litigant why the decision was made;
- Enabling the losing party to assess whether valid grounds for appeal exist; and
- Demonstrating to the public that justice has been administered in accordance with the law.
The adequacy of judicial reasons is a threshold question on appeal: where a judge fails to articulate the logical or legal foundation for an order, and that failure prevents meaningful appellate review, the court commits an error of law.
In such circumstances, the appellate court cannot grant deference to the decision below, and the order must be set aside.
Summary Proceedings and Judicial Expediency in Commercial and Property Disputes
In British Columbia, summary trial procedures under Rule 9-7 of the Supreme Court Civil Rules allow courts to determine complex matters efficiently on written affidavit evidence. Commercial landlords, commercial tenants, real estate developers, and corporate stakeholders frequently utilize summary proceedings to resolve contractual defaults, lease enforcement, property claims, and shareholder rights without the expense of a full trial.
While procedural efficiency is essential to the functioning of the civil justice system, efficiency cannot supersede judicial duty. As the BC Court of Appeal discussed, when faced with heavy chambers dockets, judges may feel tempted to grant requested orders without providing detailed oral or written reasons.
However, expediency at the trial level often leads to severe procedural unfairness.
When a court grants summary judgment without analyzing contradictory affidavits, verifying monetary assessments, or identifying applicable legal standards, the integrity of the process is compromised.
Parties involved in commercial property disagreements or complex financial proceedings cannot be bound by summary orders that lack an analytical core. As discussed in our analysis of BC Shareholder Disputes & Summary Trials, summary trial procedures are appropriate only when the trial court can find the necessary facts and apply the law justly. Where a judge issues an order without fulfilling these tasks on the record, appellate intervention becomes mandatory.
Similarly, in real estate and land title disputes—such as those examined in our article on Purchaser’s Liens & CPLs in BC Commercial Real Estate Disputes—commercial entities require absolute clarity regarding property rights and financial liabilities.
A judicial order that alters land title, imposes financial judgments, or cancels contractual obligations without explicit justification undermines commercial certainty.
In the same vein, in our representation of the family law client in Wang v. Sigouin, the Court of Appeal found that all of the chambers’ judge’s orders were legal errors and were reversed; the respondent was ordered to pay costs of the chambers hearing as well as for the appeal.
Case Analysis: Degen v. Bowers, 2026 BCCA 417
Released a few days ago, the consequences of an unreasoned judicial decision were directly addressed by the Court of Appeal for British Columbia in Degen v. Bowers.
The litigation arose from the breakdown of a marriage involving joint property, disputed financial contributions, allegations of damaged personal property, personal injury claims, and cost allocations.
The respondent filed a summary trial application seeking sweeping final orders, including a property equalization payment, compensation for damaged property, damages under a novel legal theory, and formal costs.
The appellant filed affidavit evidence opposing the requested relief but did not attend the summary trial hearing.
The chambers judge proceeded in the appellant’s absence, indicated that he had reviewed the materials, asked brief questions of counsel for the respondent, and granted virtually all orders requested.
The judge provided no written or oral reasons explaining how he resolved the conflicting factual assertions in the affidavits or how he calculated the monetary awards.
The Unexplained Orders at Issue
On appeal, the appellant challenged multiple aspects of the entered order on the basis that the trial judge failed to provide any reasons for judgment:
- Property Equalization Payment: The trial judge ordered the appellant to pay $33,631 to equalize family property and debt. The judge accepted the respondent’s calculations without addressing the appellant’s filed evidence regarding household expenses, without resolving a dispute regarding personal jewelry, and without analyzing whether certain property exclusions had been properly accounted for.
- Property Damage Compensation: The trial judge awarded $50,000 against the appellant for property allegedly damaged or disposed of. While evidence indicated that property had been damaged, counsel for the respondent acknowledged during submissions that family law generally requires market value assessments, yet requested replacement value figures. The judge accepted the replacement value figures for all items without explaining why replacement value was used instead of fair market value, and without verifying whether the evidence supported the $50,000 calculation.
- Recognition of a Novel Tort: The judge awarded $2,500 against the appellant for placing the respondent in a “false light” by posting offensive information in public locations. In doing so, the judge recognized a new civil tort in British Columbia without citing statutory authority, without reviewing common-law precedents, and without offering a single sentence of legal reasoning.
- Costs Award: The entered order directed the appellant to pay $10,000 in costs. However, no such monetary cost order had been pronounced by the judge during the hearing, and the record contained no foundation for how the $10,000 figure was reached.
The Ruling of the Court of Appeal
Writing for a unanimous court, Chief Justice Marchand (concurred in by Madam Justice Fisher and Justice Brundrett) allowed the appeal in full regarding the challenged financial and property orders and remitted the matters for a new trial.
The Court of Appeal reiterated several key principles regarding judicial reasons and appellate review:
- Duty to Explain Logical Path: While trial judges face demanding dockets, granting orders without explanation—even when one party fails to appear—is an error of law. Reasons must justify the result, inform the losing party of the basis for the decision, and permit meaningful appellate review.
- No Deference in the Absence of Reasons: Trial court decisions are normally entitled to significant deference, particularly on factual determinations and discretionary family or commercial remedies. However, Chief Justice Marchand confirmed that where a judge falls into error by drawing conclusions on legal and factual issues without any indication of their reasoning process, no deference is owed.
- Threshold Nature of Adequate Reasons: When the record does not reveal the basis of the outcome, the absence of reasons constitutes a threshold defect that invalidates the order and necessitates a new trial.
The decision in Degen v. Bowers reinforces that litigants cannot be bound by judicial determinations that lack an analytical foundation. In another word, whether in commercial litigation or complex family asset disputes, a judgment rendered without reasons cannot stand.
Anatomy of an Inadequate Judicial Decision
To determine whether a court order can be appealed for lack of reasons, litigants and commercial entities must recognize the core structural deficiencies that invalidate a judgment. Inadequate reasons generally manifest in four distinct ways:
1. Failure to Resolve Contradictory Affidavit Evidence
In summary trials, evidence is presented primarily through sworn affidavits. When affidavits contain directly conflicting accounts regarding contractual terms, asset values, corporate management, or financial liabilities, the judge must explain why one version of events is accepted over another. A judgment that simply adopts one party’s position while ignoring opposing affidavit evidence fails the test set out in Sheppard and McDougall.
2. Arbitrary Adopted Damages and Valuation Metrics
In commercial real estate disputes, lease enforcement actions, and corporate asset divisions, financial awards must be grounded in recognized valuation principles. If a court accepts a lump-sum damages figure or property valuation without explaining the methodology used—such as choosing replacement cost over market value, or applying arbitrary discount rates—the decision lacks legal rationale.
3. Unexplained Application or Expansion of Legal Principles
Trial courts are bound by statutory frameworks and established common-law precedents. When a court recognizes a new cause of action, creates novel commercial remedies, or departs from established statutory interpretation without explaining its legal authority, the order contains a fundamental legal defect.
4. Discrepancy Between Hearing Rulings and Formal Entered Orders
A court order must reflect the precise pronouncements made by the judge on the record. Where a formal written order contains terms, monetary awards, or cost directions that were never uttered by the judge during the hearing or set out in written reasons, those provisions are legally unenforceable on appeal.
Where any of these defects occur, the affected party has grounds to challenge the decision. As demonstrated in our guide on Setting Aside a Default Judgment in British Columbia, procedural fairness is a non-negotiable requirement across all stages of civil litigation. Similarly, as explored in our article on Injunctions in BC Law: Protecting Your High-Stakes Business Interests, extraordinary court orders require rigorous judicial justification before they can alter legal or financial rights.
Procedural Steps When Appealing an Unreasoned Judgment
Litigants facing an unreasoned judicial order must act quickly and strategically. The appellate process in British Columbia operates under strict statutory timelines and strict procedural rules.
Step 1: Preserve and Review the Complete Trial Record
Appellate review is conducted on the record created before the trial court. Immediately following an adverse ruling, the appellant must request the official court transcript of the hearing, including all oral remarks made by the judge, and compile all filed affidavits, exhibits, and written submissions.
Step 2: Adhere to Statutory Appeal Deadlines
Under Section 19 of the Court of Appeal Act, a notice of appeal must be filed within 30 days after the order is entered or pronounced. In commercial and property disputes, missing this statutory deadline can permanently bar relief, leaving an unreasoned order in effect.
Step 3: Frame Appeal Grounds on Correctness Standards
When appealing a decision for lack of reasons, the grounds of appeal should emphasize error of law. Findings of fact by a trial judge are reviewed on the deferential “palpable and overriding error” standard. In contrast, the question of whether judicial reasons are legally adequate is reviewed on a correctness standard. Demonstrating that the judge failed to articulate an analytical path eliminates the deferential barrier and opens the entire order to appellate scrutiny.
Step 4: Prepare for New Proceedings or Direct Relief
When the Court of Appeal allows an appeal due to inadequate reasons, the standard remedy is to set aside the order and remit the matter back to the trial court for a new trial or hearing before a different judge. In certain cases where the evidentiary record is complete and undisputed, the Court of Appeal may exercise its discretion to substitute its own decision. Counsel must evaluate which remedy best serves the client’s long-term commercial or financial objectives.
As highlighted in our analysis of Relocation & Variation in High-Stakes Vancouver Family Law, securing a clear, legally sound, and final judicial determination is essential to ending disputes permanently.
Questions and Answers: Appealing Judicial Rulings Issued Without Reasons
What constitutes “insufficient reasons” under British Columbia law?
Insufficient reasons are judicial explanations that fail to reveal the logical or legal path taken by the judge to reach a conclusion. Under British Columbia law, reasons are legally inadequate if they do not explain how major factual conflicts were resolved, fail to state the legal principles applied, prevent the unsuccessful party from understanding why they lost, or preclude the Court of Appeal from conducting a meaningful review of the decision.
Is a trial judge required to address every argument raised by counsel during a trial?
No. A judge is not required to address every line of evidence, minor argument, or precedent cited by counsel. However, a judge is legally obligated to address the decisive issues in dispute. If a party presents material affidavit evidence or a core legal defence that could alter the outcome of the case, the judge must provide sufficient explanation to show that the evidence or argument was considered and resolved.
What is the difference between brief judicial reasons and legally inadequate reasons?
Brief reasons are concise, succinct explanations that nonetheless state the judge’s key factual findings and legal conclusions. Brief reasons are legally acceptable if the record clearly explains the outcome. In contrast, legally inadequate reasons leave the reader guessing as to how the judge reached the result. If the appellate court cannot determine why the judge accepted one party’s damages calculations or ignored opposing affidavit evidence, the reasons are inadequate, regardless of their brevity.
Why did the Court of Appeal set aside the summary trial order in Degen v. Bowers?
In Degen v. Bowers, the Court of Appeal set aside the trial order because the chambers judge granted complex financial awards, equalized family property, awarded replacement-value damages, recognized a new civil tort, and entered a $10,000 costs order without providing any written or oral reasons for judgment. Chief Justice Marchand held that the judge committed an error of law by making findings on disputed factual and legal issues without revealing his reasoning process, making appellate review impossible.
How does the lack of reasons affect the deferential standard of review usually granted to trial judges?
Trial judges are usually granted significant deference on appeal, particularly regarding factual findings, credibility assessments, and discretionary orders. However, this deference is contingent on the judge providing reasons that show a logical analytical path. Where a judge provides no reasons or legally inadequate reasons, no deference is owed. The Court of Appeal reviews the threshold question of adequacy as an error of law on a correctness standard.
Can a trial judge adopt a draft order prepared by one party without providing oral or written reasons?
A trial judge cannot simply sign or adopt a party’s draft order or Scott Schedule without explaining the factual and legal basis for doing so when the underlying issues are disputed. While a judge may accept one party’s proposed calculations or remedies, the judge must independently evaluate the evidence and articulate why those remedies are legally justified. Adopting a party’s proposed order wholesale without explanation constitutes a failure of judicial duty.
What remedy does the Court of Appeal grant when an appeal succeeds based on a failure to give reasons?
When an appeal succeeds because the trial judge failed to provide adequate reasons, the Court of Appeal typically sets aside the affected portions of the order and remits the matter back to the trial court for a new trial or a new summary hearing before a different judge. In limited circumstances where the record is complete, and no credibility issues remain unresolved, the Court of Appeal may decide the substantive issues directly.
How should commercial property owners or business litigants document unreasoned rulings at trial?
Litigants should ensure that every stage of the proceeding is fully recorded. This includes ordering official court transcripts for all oral rulings, chambers discussions, and formal judgment announcements. Additionally, counsel should ensure that all filed affidavits, valuation reports, contracts, and written arguments are properly entered into the court record, providing a complete file for appellate review if the judge issues an unexplained decision.
Does an unreasoned decision automatically guarantee a successful appeal?
An unreasoned decision creates strong grounds for appeal, but success depends on showing that the lack of reasons prejudiced the appellant’s ability to understand the judgment or seek appellate review. If the basis for the trial judge’s order is completely obvious on the face of an undisputed record, the Court of Appeal may uphold the decision despite brief or flawed reasons. However, where material facts or legal standards were contested, the absence of reasons constitutes a reversible error of law.
How does an unreasoned decision impact financial remedies like damages, costs, or asset distribution?
When a trial judge awards financial damages, equalizes commercial or marital assets, or orders costs without explaining the underlying calculations or legal metrics, those awards are highly vulnerable on appeal. Financial remedies must be based on verified evidence and recognized legal standards (such as fair market value, contractual terms, or statutory framework rules). Unexplained lump-sum awards or unannounced cost figures represent legal errors that warrant set-aside on appeal.
Strategic Legal Representation in Complex Appellate Litigation
Challenging an unreasoned judicial order requires sharp analytical focus, thorough command of the trial record, and deep expertise in appellate advocacy. When a trial court issues an adverse order without explaining its legal or factual rationale, commercial property owners, executives, commercial tenants, and substantial property holders must act decisively to protect their rights.
At Roland Law, our downtown Vancouver litigation team brings extensive experience in commercial disputes, complex property division, real estate litigation, and appellate representation before the Court of Appeal for British Columbia.
We are experienced in identifying critical trial errors, preserving client entitlements, and prosecuting high-stakes appeals when judicial rulings fall short of required legal standards.
If you have received an adverse court order that lacks judicial reasons, or if you require strategic representation in a complex family law, commercial or property dispute, contact our experienced litigation counsel today. Call our Vancouver office at 604-800-4628 or submit a direct inquiry through our confidential Contact Form.